American Idol Reviews & Picks Of The Week - CLOSE RACE!

You’d think that with all the money American Idol is making, they could afford a better band. Are these people’s friends or something? Do us all a favor & spring for a better band.

So keeping in mind that the band is tres cruise ship, here are our American Idol performance reviews and picks for this week.

5701 Bo Bice – fantastic. Bo is a total pro. The reason Simon was right in his comments is only because of the band. NOT because of Bo.

5702 Jessica Sierra – An absolutely perfect performance. Go home girl!!
Remember: Simon is ALWAYS right.

5703 Anwar Robinson – Ok Anwar, here’s the deal: we all know you have a fantastic voice. But you have to put more feeling into your songs. You have to rely LESS on the power of your vocals and focus on OVERALL sound & performance quality. Remember: Simon is ALWAYS right.

5704 Nadia Turner – Great performance. WAY better than last week. But Nadia you’re still on the edge. Return to what got you this far – a fantastic soulful voice. Don’t be too edgy just now. Remember: Simon is ALWAYS right.

5705 Constantine – We LOVE Constantine!

5706 Nikko Smith – Great vocal. Great performance. I see a recording contract in your future. We’d like to see more of that unique star quality in your performances.

5707 Anthony Federov – Great! You’ve gotten back to what got you here. But remember: Simon is always right.

5708 Carrie Underwood – Excellent. Perfect. You’ve got what it takes. Remember: Simon is always right.

5709 Scott Savol – Pitchy. Scott is very likable which may carry him through. But no “it” factor. It seams like he was concentrating on his voice a lot unlike a pro from whom it just flows naturally. Remember: Simon is always right.

5710 Vonzell Solomon – Wow. Vonzell is really improving. That was hot.

Our picks:

This week on American Idol we are reminded once again just how tight this competition is. Nevertheless, someone has to go.

Our picks for who will be voted off & who will be in the bottom 3 are based on both performance & popularity.

Bottom 3: Scott Savol; Anthony Federov; Nadia Turner (because she’s not as popular as she could be if she stopped trying to be so edgy); Jessica Sierra

Vote Off: this week we think it will be Anthony Federov.